Xi sits behind every rogue state. Why is the West still bowing to him?

We must abandon our cowardly fatalism and drop the fantasy of a grand strategic reset with China

Matthew Syed

It is difficult to feel anything other than horror at the attack this month on a school used as a humanitarian shelter in the Zaporizhzhia region of Ukraine in which 55 died. We already know about the mutilation of prisoners, the mass rape of women and the kidnapping of children, but I suspect the true extent of crimes perpetrated in this pitiless war will take years to uncover.

Raise your eyes from Ukraine, though, and glimpse other evils in our benighted world. Over in Iran, an estimated 50,000 were killed in January by a regime that has tyrannised its people since gaining power in 1979 and which funds a series of proxies across the region responsible for some of the most bloody attacks, not least October 7.

Three hundred years after the Enlightenment, religious psychopathy is still alive in the 21st century.

North Korea, for its part, is a 26 million person prison camp. One of the formative experiences of my life occurred at a table tennis event in the 1990s where I approached North Korean players to ask if any fancied a practice session later that day. I’ll never forget the look of terror on their faces as they looked to one of their coaches (a member of the secret police, who rejected my request). These young men and women had been taught that the West is the enemy and that a sociopathic dynasty is their divine benefactor. I hardly slept that night. With a clarity that haunted me for weeks, I knew that I had come face to face with Orwell’s vision in 1984.

I could go on, but let me pause for a moment. I read commentaries calling Putin “this century’s Hitler” and Kim Jong-un the head of “the world’s most evil crime family”, but what provokes a sense of growing anxiety is how difficult it is to get people to perceive the bigger picture. To see what connects these regimes. To see the one man, the one nation, standing behind them, funding them, equipping them and protecting them. You might almost say coordinating them.

In the coming days Xi Jinping will host the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen. He will meet world leaders. He will be fêted. You will read reports in western newspapers about how China is set to become the dominant global power, replacing a decadent and exhausted West. You will read, too, that this is probably for the better. China is more rational, more disciplined and more reliable — certainly compared with the Keystone Kops operation in the White House. This is what passes these days for fashionable analysis.

And so we begin to feel a certain fatalism about the next chapter in world history. Perhaps this is why the UK is “leaning into” China. Why we are prioritising cheap goods over protecting our critical industries. Why The New Statesman said this year that Britain’s future “runs through China”. Why many within western nations regard China as a more reliable partner. Why centrist podcasters call for a “reset” in our relationship with the Chinese Communist Party. At least President Xi seems reasonable. I mean, doesn’t he?

I invite you to peer through this fog of moral confusion. Putin may be this century’s Hitler but he has an enabler. China provides the dual-use components for his munitions and funds Russia’s war economy with purchases of oil and gas (in August alone China took 2.64 million barrels a day of Russian crude, 41 per cent more than a year earlier). I bitterly regret Trump’s approach to this conflict but is it not worth remembering that it is Chinese parts inside the drones that westernsupplied interceptors are shooting down. China is the facilitator, funder and quartermaster of Russia’s war.

I’ve already mentioned the fundamentalism that undergirds the Iranian regime, which has killed hundreds of innocents in western nations. But who notices that it is China supplying the chemicals, electronics and components used in their attack weapons; that funds the regime with tens of billions in oil purchases; that provides diplomatic cover in the UN? Who notices that China is behind 98 per cent of North Korea’s foreign trade and consistently shielded its nuclear programme? Now a rogue state possesses vast destructive power.

China is the facilitator, funder and quartermaster of Russia’s war 

I intended in this column to examine a recent parliamentary report that critiqued the appalling cynicism in Britain’s policy towards China, which has permitted Chinese cars to flood the British market (with GPS technology that could collect sensitive data about citizens and military installations) and which remains blithely complacent about disinformation campaigns.

Chinese firms have extensive interests in Britain’s critical infrastructure and have launched cyberattacks on our telecommunications networks. Yet while Russia and Iran are subject to the highest tier of rules of the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme, China is not.

But sometimes such details can cause us to miss the bigger picture. China has effectively knitted together a strategic alliance in which Iran supplies Russia with weapons, North Korea supplies Moscow with troops and Russia provides hydrocarbons and intelligence — while Xi pretends to be a “neutral” actor concerned with “rules” and “peace”. It is the most stunning conjuring trick in modern history. What seems certain is that China’s funding of western think tanks and politicians has paid ample dividends (never forget that David Cameron’s most ambitious gambit after leaving office was not the Greensill affair but an abortive plan to become the figurehead of a $1bn China investment fund).

I hesitate to finish with America but needs must. America has changed dramatically under Trump in ways that rightly alarm us. It is important to be both wise and vigilant about how to construct alliances in this new world.

But I hope you’ll agree that there is a distinction between a democracy under strain and a dictatorship by design.

Trump can rail against journalists, but they continue to investigate him. He can rage at judges, but they continue to rule against him (including key votes in lower and higher courts in recent weeks). He can disregard public opinion, but can’t abolish the ballot box. Already it seems as if America might be moving away from its flirtation with Maga. If so, one hopes this continues.

Because this authoritarian axis answers to no courts, no free press, no voters. The only hard limits on its ambitions are those that our fractured alliance can impose. Its propagandists will of course keep coming, amplified by armies of bots, insisting that the West is decadent, that democracy is a sham and that our own failings make us as evil as the tyrannies we condemn. It is a seductive lie, but one that has found a willing audience, not just in the deranged forums of social media but also in many universities, which have been happy to accept Chinese money.

But as President Xi basks in the acclaim of a credulous world next week, I hope more than a few of us will be resisting the temptation to swoon at his “polished” diplomacy and instead think of the stolen children of Ukraine, the thousands enduring genocide in Xinjiang and the countless victims of Iran’s ayatollahs. And perhaps we might also say to the useful idiots within our own borders who insist that Britain’s future lies in cosying up to China: be careful what you wish for.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog