Football’s desire for more and more matches has wrecked another competition


Martin Samuel - The voice of sport

Martin Samuel

It would have been a great game in Madrid tonight. Spain versus England, winner takes all. But it’s not. It’s a dead rubber.

Another victim of football’s insatiable desire for content.

Matches, matches, matches.

That’s all that now matters.

Matches at overblown World Cups, in the unwieldy European Championship, qualifiers for qualifiers, safety nets beneath safety nets.

The Champions League group stage now features 144 games across five months to eliminate a grand total of 12 clubs. And now this: a competition designed to eliminate meaningless international fixtures throwing up more meaningless international fixtures.

Uefa’s Nations League had its critics when it started in 2018. I know, I was one. Didn’t see why it was necessary, didn’t understand how it bled into other Uefa qualification formats, didn’t think the summer required another competition at a time when players craved rest. Yet it worked. Better match-ups, a meaningful prize at the end. The roll call of champions proves nations genuinely want to win it. Portugal twice, plus Spain and France. Serious football cultures are paying attention. It’s not as if the continent groans, shrugs and lets Bulgaria take the trophy. Its not the Eurovision Song Contest.

It was so good, in fact, that someone at Uefa just had to spoil it. And someone did. When it started out, the Nations League was tight and elite. Having separated the A league into four groups of three, the winners progressed to produce two semi-finals and a final. Then it was expanded to four groups of four but, still, only the winners went through. And that was how it remained until the 2024-25 edition when a superfluous quarter-final round requiring two qualifiers from each group was introduced, leading to dead rubbers. Exactly what the competition was created to avoid.

This is why, in part, Thomas Tuchel has to spend so much time emphasising the importance of players turning up for international duty. England have spent the past week once again engaged in pointless matches. Admittedly, disguised well. Last Thursday was Harry Kane night as he broke England’s appearance record and today’s game is against the world champions, so neither fixture should be a hard sell. Yet as the crowd dwindled as the end approached at Wembley last week, it became clear nobody was fooled. Now second of four was good enough to qualify, England had to lose 8-0 at home to Croatia to even encounter the smallest jeopardy. Tonight, both teams are already through. What should have been a true test of England’s progress since the World Cup is another tepid bath.

“What should have been a true test of England’s progress is now a tepid bath

Under the original Nations League rules of engagement, having lost 3-2 at home to Spain, England would have had to win by two clear goals or be eliminated. For Spain, a draw would be enough, but there would still be an element of danger. England are a good team, World Cup semi-finalists. They won 3-2 in a Nations League tie in Seville in 2018. England marched on, Spain went out. But football no longer wants jeopardy. It wants match-ups.

All that is being haggled over now is the right to play a slightly weaker quarter-finalist. Yet in group A1, Italy sit first and France second, so what is the advantage anyway? England could pull off a hugely impressive win over Spain and walk into a tie against France.

The argument is that there will always be March fixtures, and at least they will now be meaningful. Yes, but November’s two group games, for Spain and England, were not. So it’s an exchange, nothing more. And how did those quarter-finals from the 2024-25 edition pan out? They were redundant. Portugal, France, Germany and Spain won the groups, and all won their quarter-finals. The same countries that would have been eliminated from the group in previous editions were simply eliminated in a knockout round instead. All that changed was increased demand on the players.

Why have an extra round of unnecessary fixtures? Might that not be what a successful team can win, too? March’s schedule cancelled. A respite from the treadmill of extended formats.

Maybe organise a friendly against an opponent from South America, Africa or Asia to add variety.

It does seem ridiculous that Lionel Messi’s first meeting with England this summer was also his last.

Yet, mostly, here was a great opportunity missed. In every sport the demand is for more, yet with each meeting the scarcity value of these encounters is devalued and mediocrity rewarded. England could lose to Spain home and away, yet end up playing Greece for the right to meet them again. The Nations League was meant to dispel the ennui of international football, yet as the final whistle blew on a half-empty Wembley Stadium on Thursday it felt increasingly that we were back were we started.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog