| Read in browser | |||||||||||||
Welcome to a special joint edition of Going Private and The Brink, Bloomberg’s twice-weekly newsletters about private markets and corporate distress. Today, we are bringing you the highlights from the Bloomberg Global Credit Forum in New York. If you’re not already on our list, sign up here. Have feedback? Email us at goingprivate@bloomberg.net or at debtnews@bloomberg.net. End of an eraPrivate credit’s honeymoon phase is drawing to a close, forcing investors to confront the consequences of a boom that has transformed the industry over the past decade. Participants at the Bloomberg Global Credit Forum at our New York HQ on Wednesday appeared to have little doubt about the challenges lying ahead. “I just believe in the laws of physics,” said Holly Kim, a co-founder of Glendon Capital Management. “I’m not saying they’re going to be wiped out, but on a relative basis, the higher the rate you charge, the higher your default should be,” she said. “Something’s got to give.”  Holly Kim, founding partner of Glendon Capital Management Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg Across panels and private conversations, investors warned that a long-delayed reckoning may finally be approaching for the direct-lending market. “The idea of low volatility in a private credit fund or a private credit structure was confused with: ‘I will never have problems in my portfolio,’” said Brett Klein, global head of corporate credit at Sculptor Capital. “The investor base is recognizing that the double-digit returns in private credit are several hundred basis points lower.” The golden era of private credit came on the back of the increase in interest rates, which coincided with banks pulling back from lending. Private credit investors filled in the liquidity gap — in some cases offering first-lien loans with more than 10% interest. That phase is now over. Mainstream lenders are back in the market, emboldened by regulatory moves to loosen capital constraints. Competition to lend has slashed returns private credit funds needed to compensate for more flexible terms. Managers have so far been able to paper over some of the cracks, but the excesses of the previous era are getting harder to ignore. GoldenTree Asset Management Founder & CIO Steve Tananbaum, one of the market’s most closely-watched veteran investors, said it was a “tough time” to be in credit. While there has been a broader rally versus equities over the last few weeks, credit has still languished and that lag was set to continue.   Private credit has already faced a series of setbacks this year. A huge bet on software companies vulnerable to displacement by artificial intelligence has led to questions about credit quality and how fund managers value their loans. The default rate in the sector reached 6% as of the end of April, a record high since the inception of Fitch Ratings’ gauge, according to the ratings firm. However, many restructurings and default events are still not captured in public reporting — a market convention that’s stirring questions among regulators and some participants. But where some see danger, others spot an opportunity. Diameter Capital Partners is among the firms looking to buy private credit loans from business development companies that are seeking to sell amid redemption pressure, said Scott Goodwin, the firm’s co-founder. He said it’s “way too early” to buy up distressed software debt now — the AI boom has only just begun. But as BDCs and other private credit vehicles come under pressure, “they’re going to sell their highest-quality software loans at some discount to par. We’ll be interested in those.” `No sense’Forum attendees also highlighted the uncomfortable gap for companies paying off large debt stacks taken in the heyday years of 2020 and 2021 at today’s higher rates. Some said these positions look unsustainable as loans set with floating-rate interest ratchet up along with Federal Reserve policy. “Some capital structures out there simply don’t make sense today,” said Suzanne Gibbons, head of research at Davidson Kempner. “What’s going to start materializing is the disappointment that losses are going to be a lot worse than people think.” With the gap between reported and adjusted earnings wider by about two turns, loans that appear to have a 45% loan-to-value ratio are effectively closer to 65%, she said.  Suzanne Gibbons, partner and head of research at Davidson Kempner Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg Under-pressure private equity owners foisting losses on investors in their most troubled companies may also be running out of road. Investors are losing patience with strategies known as liability management exercises, which can help to stave off more formal debt restructuring, but often just delay the inevitable. The investor experience in LMEs, for the most part, “has been bad,” according to Brett Klein, global head of corporate credit at Sculptor Capital. Now they’re saying “no more, this has gone too far” and asking “why don’t you just file the company for bankruptcy?” Lenders are themselves getting squeezed as banks pull back leverage. In turn, they’re increasing the spreads they’re demanding to do deals — or passing them up altogether. Na Wei, global head of leveraged finance at Barclays, said one client told her they got the impression that the firms were “bidding to lose.” Just over a third of the audience at the New York event said they felt stagflation posed the biggest risk to credit markets, a survey of attendees found. As war in the Middle East grinds on — and with it the pressure on consumer prices — global markets are still “aggressively embracing the view that all will be fine,” said Lotfi Karoui, managing director and multi-asset credit strategist at Pimco.  Christina Lee, managing director and co-portfolio manager at Oaktree Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg Clayton’s vowAmong the doom and gloom over future of private credit, it was down to Jay Clayton, the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, to underscore the strengths and benefits of a thriving private credit market. “Take a look at the US markets over the last 20 years and compare them to the European markets in terms of regulation and operation,” said Clayton, who once headed the SEC and sat on the board of Apollo. “The growth differential, one of the principal drivers of that, is the availability of private credit, he said. “It’s not much more complicated than that,” he said. Clayton also argued that lending mistakes are part of any ordinary market — but that he’s committed to rooting out any “shenanigans” in private assets, including around divergent marks of the same loan.  Jay Clayton, US Attorney for the Southern District of New York Valuation has emerged as one of the most contentious issues in the asset class and global guardians of financial stability have vowed to pay special attention to signs of bad practice. Because private loans rarely trade in secondary markets, fund managers cannot rely on observable market prices to value their holdings. Instead, they must estimate those valuations internally, often with assistance from specialist valuation firms. Clayton said one of the hardest things about being a regulator is “distinguishing between incompetence and bad judgment,” and that is one reason why current reporting regulations exist. They are supposed to provide information about risks or performance, and “also designed to discipline you and show the difference between incompetence and ill intent,” he said. In Their Words“There’s no such thing as good PIK, There’s only bad PIK, so less PIK is better.” Susan Kasser Head of Private Debt at Neuberger Berman In a risk-off environment, investors are seeking out forward-looking indicators, including the percentage of a coupon in so-called ‘payment-in-kind’ as opposed to cash. The Number$400-$500 billion Anish Shah, global head of debt capital markets at Morgan Stanley, says AI capex and related funding could approach 15% of all issuance across credit markets, with new capital being raised across the credit spectrum. “And just to put that in context, two years ago, this wasn’t a sector that was being financed in the market,” he said. Movers and ShakersDiameter Capital Partners is hiring graduates straight from college for the first time because they offer different skills from those who grew up working in credit.  Scott Goodwin, co-founder and managing partner of Diameter Capital Partners Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg The firm historically took on candidates after they did training programs elsewhere because “that was a tax on us to train them but now the AI nativity of the college grads is so powerful that we’ve hired a number of them this year,” co-founder Scott Goodwin said at the Bloomberg Global Credit Forum in New York. “I think that number is only going to grow.” Graduates have complained of fewer opportunities as the rise of AI reduces the need for some entry level roles. For more experienced finance workers, Standard Chartered Chief Executive Officer Bill Winters has also warned that an increased focus on the technology could lead to the elimination of roles. More From BloombergCheck out these newsletters:
Explore all newsletters at Bloomberg.com. We’re improving your newsletter experience and we’d love your feedback. If something looks off, help us fine-tune your experience by reporting it here. Follow Us
You received this message because you are subscribed to Bloomberg’s Going Private newsletter. If a friend forwarded you this message, sign up here to get it in your inbox.
|
Comments
Post a Comment